Strategic Hires vs. Vacancies: Understanding the Spectrum of Roles in an Organisation
In executive search, we often say:“We work on strategic hires, not just vacancies.” But what does that really mean? To understand the value of ex...
Connecting...
In executive search, we often say:“We work on strategic hires, not just vacancies.” But what does that really mean? To understand the value of executive search and why certain roles require a more strategic approach, it’s helpful to look at the different types of roles that exist within an organisation—and how they differ in purpose, impact, and the way they are filled.
Definition: These are the roles that keep the business running. From customer service reps and logistics coordinators to finance analysts and IT support, operational roles are essential for execution.
Characteristics:
Clearly defined responsibilities
Often high-volume or repeatable tasks
Easier to hire through internal recruiters, job boards, or contingency firms
Typically replaced when someone leaves — i.e.,filling a vacancy
When they're hired: Often in reaction to a resignation, expansion, or process bottleneck.
Definition: These roles are often specialised and may include mid-level managers, technical experts, or project leads. They connect strategy to execution.
Characteristics:
Require deeper expertise or domain knowledge
May influence decision-making, but aren't typically setting long-term direction
Hiring may still be reactive, but requires more careful sourcing and vetting
When they're hired: Often as part of a growth initiative or when scaling a department.
Definition: These are the roles that impact the long-term trajectory of a company—think C-suite, VP-level, or transformative leadership roles. They are not always “vacant” in the traditional sense.
Characteristics:
Influence company vision, direction, or culture
Critical to competitive advantage and market positioning
May not exist yet—they are often created, not just filled
Require a bespoke search process to find the right mix of experience, values, and leadership style
When they're hired: Often proactively, in anticipation of a change in direction, a new market opportunity, or a planned evolution in leadership.
This is where executive search differs from traditional recruitment. Many of the roles we’re engaged to fill are not about replacing someone—they’re about finding someone the business doesn’t have yet but will need to grow, compete, or evolve.
Examples of strategic hires:
Building a digital transformation capability
Bringing in a growth-focused CFO ahead of a fundraising round
Adding a Chief People Officer to scale culture globally
Hiring a GM to open a new market or region
These are transformative roles, not transactional ones. They require:
Deep market intelligence
Discreet outreach to passive candidates
Assessment of leadership traits, not just skills
Alignment with long-term business goals
Recognising the distinction between operational, tactical, and strategic roles helps organisations plan more effectively—and hire more intelligently. Filling a vacancy is about today. Making a strategic hire is about tomorrow.
So, when we say we focus on strategic hires, it’s because we’re not just filling gaps. We’re helping companies build capability—often before the need is even obvious.